Just when it seemed the crisis in the eurozone might be heading toward some kind of resolution, European financial regulators have managed to drag the continent back into doom and gloom. This time, the culprit is Cyprus, whose rickety banking system is heavily exposed to nasty things like Greek debt. Intense negotiations over the weekend produced the latest bailout agreement, which will raid the bank accounts of ordinary Cypriots in order to finance the bad behavior of Cypriot bankers. As David Bosco tweeted last night, "were the Eurozone ministers and IMF reps drinking during the 10-hour meeting that produced the Cyprus levy?"
Furious at the prospect of financing another bailout out of their own pocket, the Germans -- and their henchmen at the IMF and the European Central Bank -- made an offer to Cypriot President Nicos Anastasiades that he couldn't refuse. Here's how the Wall Street Journal says it all happened:
Just after 5 p.m., finance ministers, IMF Managing Director Christine
Lagarde, ECB executive board member Jörg Asmussen and the EU's
economic-affairs commissioner, Olli Rehn, filed into a meeting room on
the fifth floor of Brussels's Justus Lipsius, which houses the EU's
ministerial meetings and summits. Cyprus's newly elected President Nicos
Anastasiades stayed behind in the country's delegation room on the
seventh floor, ready to approve or reject any potential deals.
Mr. Rehn was the first to make a specific proposal. To raise funds,
Cyprus should impose a special levy on deposits, taxing accounts of less
than €100,000 at 3%, those up to €500,000 at 5% and those above at 7%.
Such a "solidarity levy "-the brainchild of Thomas Wieser, an Austrian
who chairs technical discussion among euro-zone finance officials, and
Mr. Asmussen- could avoid a straight "haircut" on deposits, which they
feared could be too destabilizing for Cyprus and the rest of Europe. The
tax would be applied to all Cypriot banks, not just the two in deep
But Ms. Lagarde had something else in
mind. The IMF chief presented a much more radical plan, in which
deposits above €100,000 in Laiki and Bank of Cyprus would have been cut
by between 30% and 40%. The owners of senior bonds in the two banks
would also have faced losses-a step that was ultimately rejected. That
plan would have limited the international bailout to €10 billion and
raise some €7.5 billion from depositors.
Take a moment and consider those figures. According to the Journal, Christine Lagarde -- apparently with a straight face -- asked for a 30 to 40 percent reduction in large deposits to finance the misadventures of Cypriot banks.
After some more squabbling back and forth during which Anastasiades rejected IMF demands, the financial officials decided to play hardball with the newly minted president. The following exchange, as reported by the Journal, might serve as a case study for how to stick up a bank in the year 2013:
At that point, around 1 a.m. a small group-including Ms. Lagarde, Mr.
Rehn, Mr. Sarris, Mr. Schäuble, France's Pierre Moscovici, Mr. Asmussen
and Mr. Dijsselbloem broke off into a separate room. It was then -- as
other ministers snoozed or played on their iPads -- that Mr. Asmussen told
Mr. Anastasiades that without a deal, Cyprus's two big banks faced
insolvency, since they would have no prospect of European funds to
repair their battered capital buffers, said people who were present. In
that case, the ECB would no longer be willing to fund the banks with
central-bank emergency liquidity, Mr. Asmussen said, these people said.
The implication: The island's biggest banks might be unable to reopen
after Monday's bank holiday.
Mr. Asmussen backed up the warning by calling ECB President Mario Draghi and letting him know the central bank might have to deal with the collapse of Cyprus's banks.
After managing to secure a concession that no deposit be taxed at a rate above 10 percent, Anastasiades signed the agreement.
It's worth noting that the arrangement foisted upon Cyprus by regulators is also completely unprecedented in the history of the meandering European response to the financial crisis. While so-called "haircuts" have been imposed in the past -- notably on holders of Greek bonds -- European financial authorities have never had the temerity to pull money straight out of individual bank accounts in order to rescue banks.
Beyond the unprecedented nature of the move, the decision to impose a one-time tax on deposits now threatens the broader European financial system. In an effort to reduce their exposure to the tax, Cypriots flocked en masse to the country's ATMs over the weekend -- to the extent that many machines ran out of cash. With fears that Italy and Spain may also require bailout packages, depositors in those countries have to be wondering whether they too should begin moving money out of their local banks to avoid a similar tax. That may very well result in a run on banks in the two countries least equipped to handle it.
The wrinkle in the Cypriot bailout is what might be called the Russian connection. As Dylan Matthews explains, the Cypriot government has gotten in bed with the Russian government to offer a less-than-above-board financial haven to Russians looking for a friendly locale to park their money. Facing a revolt at home, Anastasiades is now trying to renegotiate the terms of the bailout. If he is able to increase rates for large deposits and lower the rate for smaller holdings, Russian oligarchs could be footing a sizable portion of the bill for the Cypriot bailout.
The question for Anastasiades now is this: Whom can he afford to infuriate more -- mom-and-pop Cypriot depositors or the Russian mob?
Yiannis Kourtoglou/AFP/Getty Images