Criticizing a column by Charles Krauthammer is an action roughly akin to shooting fish in a barrel, but today's offering contains a particularly egregious distortion:
On Tuesday, one day before the president touted passage of a surpassingly weak U.N. resolution and declared Iran yet more isolated, the leaders of Russia, Turkey and Iran gathered at a security summit in Istanbul "in a display of regional power that appeared to be calculated to test the United States," as the New York Times put it. I would add: And calculated to demonstrate the hollowness of U.S. claims of Iranian isolation, to flaunt Iran's growing ties with Russia and quasi-alliance with Turkey, a NATO member no less.
Growing ties with Russia? Not so fast, Chuck.
First, need I point out that Russia did, in fact, vote for the resolution in question?
Second, back in May, Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad ticked off the Russians when he strongly implied that Russia was becoming an enemy of the Iranian people. Here's how Reuters characterized the Russian response:
The Kremlin swiftly chastised the Iranian leader for "political demagoguery" and Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov on Thursday described Ahmadinejad's tirade as "emotional".
He said Iran had for years failed to respond to Moscow's efforts to resolve the dispute over nuclear work seen by the West as having military purposes, a charge Tehran denies.
This is not to say that Moscow is ready to overthrow the mullahs or simply go along with U.S. plans to put the hurt on Tehran. Russia's interests in Iran are primarily commerical, as was clear from Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov's comments this week. (''We ensured the absolute protection of all the vitally important trade channels that exist between Russia and Iran ... The U.N. resolution doesn't create any barriers in this sense.'') He also indicated, however, that Iran wouldn't be allowed to join the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, the Beijing-led security group focused on Central Asia.
Ahmadinejad has an interesting personal history with Russia. Back in 1979, according to the Atlantic's Mark Bowden, he voted against occupying the U.S. Embassy in Tehran, favoring a demonstration in front of the Soviet Embassy instead. A fellow student radical later described the future president's thinking in a BBC documentary thusly: "Mr. Ahmadinejad said it will boost the Soviets’ influence -- the real threat to the revolution is Russia and the Marxists."
There is a long history of Russian interference in Iran, including one of the first crises of the Cold War -- Joseph Stalin's refusal in 1946 to end the Soviet occupation of vast swaths of the country. It was only after the massive application of pressure by then U.S. President Harry Truman that the Soviets agreed to withdraw. This history is no doubt widely remembered in Iran today, even as the regime looks for lifelines wherever it can find them.
Passport, FP’s flagship blog, brings you news and hidden angles on the biggest stories of the day, as well as insights and under-the-radar gems from around the world.