For those of you who don't subscribe to the bimonthly print edition of Foreign Policy, you're missing a great feature: the FP Quiz. It has eight intriguing questions about how the world works.

The question I'd like to highlight this week is:

If the United States deported all its illegal immigrants at once, how long would the bus convoy be?

a) 18 miles    b) 180 miles    c) 1,800 miles

Answer after the jump ...

Answer:

C, 1,800. To deport the 12 million illegal immigrants in the United States en masse, it would take more than 200,000 buses, stretching more than 1,800 miles, according to a December 2009 Center for American Progress (CAP) report. (I did the math, and that would amount to 47.5 feet per bus and 60 people per bus. Of course, in real life, some people would have to be sent home via airplane.)

The cost would be nearly $300 billion over five years, the think tank estimates. (I did the math again, and that would be 110 buses per day at a cost of $25,000 per illegal immigrant, which presumably includes the costs of apprehension, detention, legal proceedings, and transport, based on the methodology in this 2005 CAP report, which uses older numbers.)

Arguing that this type of undertaking is unrealistic, the 2009 report says immigration reform must resolve the status of unauthorized residents; otherwise, they're receiving "amnesty by inaction."

How logistically realistic do you think mass deportation would be, given that the United States is capable of sending men to the moon?

(And for more questions about how the world works, check out the rest of the FP Quiz.)

(In the photo above, South Korean buses near the border with North Korea transport tourists from the North's Kumgang resort on July 13, 2008.) 

JEON YOUNG-HAN/AFP/Getty Images

 

OSTARDANIEL

11:17 PM ET

May 5, 2010

says immigration reform must

says immigration reform must resolve the status of unauthorized residents

motor wiper blades

 

HOMER

5:12 AM ET

May 6, 2010

Trivia

Interesting piece of trivia. It doesn't really provide any clue to solving the illegal immigration issue, whichever side you are on.

It will, I'm sure, incite both sides of the issue to completley miss the point and suggest incredibly crazy solutions.

 

CEPHAS

12:54 PM ET

May 6, 2010

ship them out!

Who needs buses, boats hold a lot more people and won't clog roads .

 

CEPHAS

12:56 PM ET

May 6, 2010

by the way...

The numbers are skewed too, you could hire private contractors to do it for a third the cost.

 

MITZY

2:20 PM ET

May 7, 2010

Buses?

I thought the Arizonans favored boxcars.

 

LOU80

12:10 PM ET

May 27, 2010

Homer's spot on

I agree with Homer's reply. Regardless of which side you are on, surely it's better to discuss this logically, rather than resort to sensationalism?

Fact is, illegal immigration is a strain on a country's resources, especially in economic hardship, but at the same time, the US was built on immigration and illegal immigrants are doing the jobs most legal US citizens wont.

So, lets get thinking about productive, compasionate ways of dealing with this, shall we?

Lou at Acai Berry Scam

 

Passport, FP’s flagship blog, brings you news and hidden angles on the biggest stories of the day, as well as insights and under-the-radar gems from around the world.

Read More