As mentioned in the brief, Tanzania and Zambia were rebuffed today in their attempts to relax the international ban on ivory sales at the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species in Doha. The decision is being hailed as a victory for conservationists after some setbacks earlier in the week: 

The rulings were a rare victory for environmentalists at the two-week meeting where they have endured defeats of proposals ranging from an export ban on Atlantic bluefin tuna to a shark conservation plan to a measure to regulate trade of red and pink corals.

Not that I approve of killing elephants for their ivory, but the economic double-standard at work here seems troubling. The tuna ban, for instance, was strongly opposed by Japan, which imports 80 percent of the world's bluefin and led a concerted lobbying effort to have the current rules overturned.

Japan has, for years, employed a similar strategy in its campaign to loosen restrictions on whaling, exchanging foreign aid to disinterested countries like Togo and St. Kitts who join the International Whaling Comission and vote with the pro-whaling bloc. Economist Christian Dippel has studied this phenomenon and wrote about it in a recent piece for FP.  

Aid-receiving countries like Tanzania and Zambia presumably don't have the resources to mount such a campaign, which is a large part of the reason they want the ban lifted in the first place. As Zambia's Minister of Tourism, Environment and Natural Resources Catherine Namugala put it, "We can't justify failure to take a child to school because we are using resources to conserve elephants. I appeal to allow Zambia to utilize the natural resources given to us by God."

Again, I tend to side with the conservationists on this, but I certainly understand the frustration of poor-country governments who are expected to make economic sacrifices for the sake of endangered species while the world's second-largest economy continues to hunt species on the brink of extinction. 

Update: New protections for hammerhead and white-tip sharks have also been shot down. Guess who led the opposition to them.

ROBERTO SCHMIDT/AFP/Getty Images

 

BOREDWELL

10:44 PM ET

March 22, 2010

Dead or Alive

And who will actually benefit from the sale of ivory? How many animals do they intend to cull (only the most mature with the longest tusks will fetch the best price; this will also encourage poachers)? And what is the estimated take in Euros/dollars of this haul? How long would it take for the anticipated revenue to trickle down to fund and improve social welfare programs? And what it the estimated cost of these programs? The logic that ivory will build schools and improve literacy is flawed. It assumes that a single source of revenue is the solution to an economic deficiency when, in fact, it's more likely a combination of many factors including poverty, distribution of wealth, inadequate management of resources, lack of political will. Zambia and Tanzania has reaped revenue from elephant- tourism. What it has done with it is another story.

 

FLORIDADUDE

10:05 AM ET

April 20, 2010

Flawed Economics

I agree with boredwell. Apparently if you want something to pass just say it will help the economy and its for the kids. Though elephant poaching is wrong, it can't be that hard to come up with more logical explanations.
costa rica guided tours

 

SCOTTM2009

5:00 PM ET

March 23, 2010

FP description of Gitmo detainee order

"A U.S. Federal Judge has ordered the release of Mohamedou Slahi, a Mauritanian national who is suspected of links to the 9/11 hijackers and was tortured while in custody at Guantanamo Bay. "

Really? He "was tortured"? According to whom? Careful FP - your bias is showing.

 

NAGOYA

6:27 AM ET

April 20, 2010

It would be definitely great

It would be definitely great for the beings. They should get use to the new surrounding soon. Nagoya Tantei

 

VIJ

11:12 AM ET

April 17, 2010

Lion Statue

Wildlife must be protected, especially the endangered species. Even here in India Elephant tusk smuggling is on the rampage and the authorities are trying their best to curb it.
Lion Statue

 

MORGANJAMES

8:20 AM ET

April 20, 2010

they need new industries

It's unfortunate that these countries have to rely on such methods to boost their economy. What they really need are alternative industries and methods in order to get their economies moving that don't involve hunting endangered species.

 

ORRIS

10:32 PM ET

April 21, 2010

Facing extinction

Maybe there should be a rule that no one is allowed to use common sense. Common sense is rare, therefore perhaps it is near extinction, at least in my generation. Do you ever wonder, what generation do I belong to?

 

FLURGLE

3:40 PM ET

April 17, 2010

Disgraceful

All wildlife whether protected or not should be treated the same, what gives anyone the right to differentiate between animals. All of gods creatures were put on this earth for a reason, what gives us the right to decide which species lives or dies.

Sky Bingo

 

TOM SAWYER

4:37 PM ET

April 17, 2010

Wildlife should be protected to the extrem.

At the rate protected wildlife is being killed of it is a wierd that there is not more opposition turning up that would really be a hard line opposition to all sorts of poaching protected animals.
It would really be nice to get some insurance that the future is not bare of a multitude of animals.

 

VIJ

1:34 AM ET

April 18, 2010

Poaching

Poaching and cruelty on animals must be stopped, period.
Parrot Talking and Large Parrot Cage

Sincerely
Dr vij
href="http://www.menstrualproblems.org">Menstrual Cramps Center

 

RUTHTYLOR

10:57 AM ET

April 19, 2010

wildlife

You have an interesting point of view, I must admit, I never thought about it that way.
Thank you for lighting that up for me.
Girl Games

 

PLOIXI

4:55 PM ET

April 19, 2010

I don't know why so many

I don't know why so many people and country only want money but not the live or death of the animals. Perhaps this is human nature, no, shouble be some one's nature, not everyone. socks proxy list.

 

FUNDOS88

4:21 AM ET

April 20, 2010

It is not shocking at all. At

It is not shocking at all. At least we know what is waiting ahead. Thanks for the sharing and good luck for the actors. palo alto counseling

 

RONIBEN

3:27 PM ET

April 21, 2010

Agree

It would be definitely great for the beings. They should get use to the new surrounding soon, very funny title but the content is highly important
ben 10 games

 

KWANH

3:10 PM ET

April 20, 2010

no choice

In these kind of countries sometimes people have no choice other than destroying nature since there is no job for most of them.
They need to be supported first by developed countries to build a relatively strong economy before being judged.
Yemek Tarifleri

 

FRANCOLT91

8:13 AM ET

April 21, 2010

Outraged

Neither of the two animals deserves the right to be treated inhumanely. I am pretty sure PETA is outraged by these issues. I just hope people will be educated and responsible enough to stop the killing of these animals.

 

DALEANN8875

7:34 PM ET

April 21, 2010

IF people would stop buying

IF people would stop buying these things, then there wouldn't be much issues. They wouldn't really bother about the elephants if they knew that people aren't interested.
My opinion though, these people are poor & practically have no future. Its hard for people like those in PETA who have the luxury of comfort & education to understand. To them, everything is black & white that there is absolutely no justification for killing of animals. I'm not saying that these people are right in wanting to go after the rest of the elephants especially since they're endangered but instead of criticizing them in their decision, why not help them instead. Help them find other sources of livelihood instead of just telling them to stop the killing. And while they're at it, make everything fair, rich country or poor!
Dale Diätfrei Abnehmen

 

Passport, FP’s flagship blog, brings you news and hidden angles on the biggest stories of the day, as well as insights and under-the-radar gems from around the world.

Read More