The real news from Clinton's stop in Congo

Tue, 08/11/2009 - 5:08pm

It's too bad that much of the attention from Hillary Clinton's trip to the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) has come from a rare off-the-cuff remark clarifying to a university student that she, not her husband, was the U.S. secretary of state. Because the real story is far more dramatic than that mini drama: it's the fact that Clinton went to Congo in the first place, that she went to the eastern, war-torn city of Goma, and that she talked tough on a few key things.

Goma is the epicenter of the violence that has torn the DRC apart for the last decade and a half. There are no diplomatic-bubble hotels in Goma. There are no five-star restaurants. Clinton's plane couldn't even land there; she had to take a United Nations flight instead. And once you arrive, there's no hiding the reality on the ground. Clinton knew that, and she went anyway: "It was very important for me to go to Goma," she explained yesterday. "A lot of concerns were raised and many objections. And I said, I know we can get there and we're going." She's already won points in my book.

Clinton's comments about human rights -- speaking out about rape, for example, rightfully caught a lot of attention. But here's a few more subtle messages that she sent that could prove equally important: 

1) "The Congolese military has to be better trained. It has to be paid." Simple as it sounds, this message is anything but. DRC is home to the largest U.N. peacekeeping mission -- a force that has still struggled to keep control over a vast country the size of Western Europe. If that is ever to change, the national army will have to fill the gap. The trouble is, for now, soldiers go unpaid, healthcare is limited if it exists at all, and training is spotty at best. No wonder soldiers are among those implicated in stealing, pillaging, and yes, rape; a steady salary would go a long way. If the government in Kinshasa isn't up to the task, a strong-stomached donor should be sought.

2) "Right now, the benefits from [Congo's] resources are not ending up broadly developing the country." The economy is at the center of Congo's crisis, and to think it's not would have been to miss half the briefing book. It will be a miracle to reverse the resource curse that has overtaken Congo since the moment it became a Belgian colony over 100 years ago. But Clinton sounds like she's ready to push for the best available option: "The model that Botswana used when it discovered diamonds -- it made sure there was a trust fund created for the country so that all of the money didn’t leave the country."

3) "I’m aware of the commitment that China has made, and I think that building roads is a very important development goal for this country. But so is good governance." DRC is in the process of considering an offer from China in which Beijing would build infrastructure for the Congo -- with deposits of some of the world's most lucrative minerals for collateral. Opinions about the deal are surely mixed (the IMF is worried that it will just incur further debt for Congo), but some good roads wouldn't hurt the country, and they would probably do more for many of its people than the last several decades of foreign mineral contracts ever have

What did the secretary leave out? Surely lots -- and more specifics about mining are at the top of that list. U.S. companies are among those interested or involved in extraction in the country. Of course, Clinton doesn't speak for private interests, but her voice is certainly heard. Strong words and committments on the U.S. side -- for monitoring of the transparency and legality of U.S. operations in the country -- would have gone a long way.

Off to Nigeria, for more tough talk.

Photo: ROBERTO SCHMIDT/AFP/Getty Images

( filed under: )


Advertisement

 

Abuja needs a Hillary outburst

I really hope to GOD that Hillary delivers on the tough talk in Abuja, Nigeria. The elite of the PDP ruling party and some of their cronies who will no doubt be swarming all around her are hard at work to hasten the slide that Nigeria is going through.

She needs to ratchet up the outburst on display in the Congo for her audience today. Especially at her meetings with Ojo Maduekwe, Yar'Adua and Obasanjo.

There's more here on what she should pay attention to - http://foreignpolicyexchange.blogspot.com/2009/08/hillary-in-nigeria.html

Thanks for this- it's one of

Thanks for this- it's one of the best commentaries on her trip to Goma I've seen- the media still is hung up on the "I'm not going to channel my husband" business- I guess that's easier to cover than the difficult issues of conflict minerals, rape as a weapon of war and Secretary Clinton's unusually blunt statements to leaders in the DRC.

While some will say 'talk is cheap', no other Secretary of State has traveled to this dangerous region and it sends a powerful message and will hopefully shed more light on one of the most under-reported atrocities in the news today. And of course, hopefully it will spurn more action on the part of Congo's leaders and the US government.

With the help of Melanie Verveer, her global ambassador for women's rights, I don't think Secretary Clinton is going to let this issue fall by the way-side.

*************
Secretary Clinton Blog

Talk about being sidelined;

Talk about being sidelined; Obama's made Clinton into an irrelevancy. I mean, with all of the challenges we face she's in Africa. Wow. Obama made a brilliant move to neuter her in this role. Her political career seems over; no wonder her frustration is coming out with these remarks.

American mining in Congo

Dan Rather Reports did a good documentary on how the U.S. government helped American mining company Freeport McMoRan pillage Congo's richest copper mine. Freeport bought the mine with the help of $300 million in financing from the U.S. government's Overseas Private Investment Corp.; and it managed to get the mine under sweetheart terms thanks to lobbying from a diplomat at the U.S. embassy in Kinshasa...who was then hired to work for the mining company just a few months after the deal was signed.
I think the segment is available on iTunes. It was called "All Mine."