Posted By Michael Wilkerson Share

The State Department's two Twitter accounts and fancy-looking blog serve as a testament to the government's effort to keep up with technology trends. And soon, if they're lucky, State employees might even get to use Firefox.

At Hillary Clinton's recent town hall meeting, State and USAID employees lined up to let her know what they think (seen above). When relatively new hire Jim Finkle requested the browser Clinton needed some backup from Under Secretary Patrick Kennedy:

[FINKLE]: Can you please let the staff use an alternative web browser called Firefox? I just – (applause) – I just moved to the State Department from the National Geospatial Intelligence Agency and was surprised that State doesn’t use this browser. It was approved for the entire intelligence community, so I don’t understand why State can’t use it. It’s a much safer program. Thank you. (Applause.)

SECRETARY CLINTON: Well, apparently, there’s a lot of support for this suggestion. (Laughter.) I don’t know the answer. Pat, do you know the answer? (Laughter.)

UNDER SECRETARY KENNEDY: The answer is at the moment, it’s an expense question. We can --

[FINKLE]: It’s free. (Laughter.)

UNDER SECRETARY KENNEDY: Nothing is free. (Laughter.) It’s a question of the resources to manage multiple systems. It is something we’re looking at...

Clinton went on to say that State had requested money for IT upgrades and she hopes Firefox works out. She also encouraged the audience to let her know of other ways the government can save money to use for similar upgrades in the future. 

While they are upgrading, if Clinton really wants to increase productivity at Foggy Bottom, I think there is a clear solution: iPhones for everyone. Ohmygov! already has a guide to "11 iPhone apps to make your government job easier."

(H/T: Katherine Mangu-Ward at Reason.) 

Mark Wilson/Getty Images

 

BUYACAI

9:20 PM ET

July 22, 2009

Firefox is the best

Clinton would permit the employees to use firefox. Firefox is always fast and easy to use. Buy Acai

 

MELVSCOTT77

2:05 AM ET

July 23, 2009

Good

http://badcredit-motorcycleloans.com

 

I4647

8:16 AM ET

July 23, 2009

Great idea, but they're right - very hard to do.

Firefox is certainly wonderful - I haven't used Microsoft's IE at home in years - but as a government IT guy at another agency, I know the barriers to rolling out firefox are pretty high:

1) All our existing web applications would need to be tested and modified to work on both IE and Firefox. Right now, we only test against IE, so this would double the work for our developers.

2) Firefox is harder to patch - you can't allow the web based autopatch most people use at home in an office. The traffic from, say, 1000 pc's all downloading the new version of firefox on the same day would slow our internet connection to a crawl. Even if you could use other methods (which do exist) to patch, it would involve managing, testing and deploying a whole new set of patches - not something taken on lightly.

3) Firefox doesn't integrate as closely with Microsoft's Group Policy Objects - meaning it is much harder, if not impossible, to lock down and standardize across hundreds or thousands of PC's. FISMA and the FDCC require that browsers be locked down and disable many otherwise handy features (password saving, as just one example), which we don't have any way to enforce in Firefox. An open source project called FrontMotion is working on an offshoot of Firefox that has GPO hooks in it, but it is still far from ready for deployment in a government environment, especially one with the security concerns that State has.

So I know it's tempting to bash State brass for seeming to give the idea the blow off, but they're 100% right in this case, and it seems like they've been listening to their IT folks, which is nice for a change.

 

QUANG VAN

12:45 PM ET

July 23, 2009

Firefox is better then IE!

Wow can't believe they wasn't able to use Firefox before. No wonder all the virus problems the government is having etc.

Wouldn't be the case with Firefox, but yeah good point about the cost of managing two systems. Though I doubt there are a lot of web based applications that they are using.

When they were developing them, it should of been cross compatible anyways.

--------------
Quang Van
Got Rich Online.com
http://twitter.com/QuangVan

 

WAYAN

7:21 PM ET

July 23, 2009

The IT Department is the Problem

Oh my god. Reading the "Government IT Guy" response sent chills down my spine. His complaints go from foolish to worse.

1. Just use Firefox - no need to test against IE then. That's what the innovative firms have been doing since 2002.

2. Can't handle patch traffic? Please. More bandwidth used by everyone updating Microsoft and IE virus/vulnerability patches than Firefox.

3. I don't even know to answer this, the very proposition that IT department's role is to lock down the user experience is so repulsive to me that I shudder with disgust.

The IT department, like all support groups, is to make the front line staff's job easier and more productive. To increase their efficiency, even if that means the IT department has to work harder. Reducing functionality, and disabling handy features is the converse, and totally illogical. In fact, its responses like this that have crippled State & AID productivity.

My favorite - USAID funds contractors to develop solutions in Google Earth, but thanks to overzealous Government IT Guys, USAID can't view their own solutions at their offices. They have to come to ours to see what they bought.

 

I4647

11:56 PM ET

July 23, 2009

1) A lot of the web apps many

1) A lot of the web apps many agencies use are old, flaky and weren't well designed - no argument there - which means many of them won't work with Firefox. The web based time clock system my agency is an easy example - it's nearly 10 year old cold fusion and javascript code, and it would require a major rewrite to run in firefox. But it works just fine in IE. Hopefully someday, we'll have functionality requirements that justify a rewrite, and you'd better believe we'll be pushing for a browser independent implementation. But until then, and in this economy, the old system still works fine, and it's got a lot of other old web app company.

2) Firefox, prior to 3.5 doesn't patch - it does full, in place upgrades. Meaning each download is very large (7mb), instead of a small patch with IE. Firefox 3.5 changes this, but there is still no go way to ensure that users don't disable the autopatch function. So you're stuck pushing out new the entire installer pack for each new version via MSI's and GPO's at 7.5mb a pop, and with Firefox updates coming out every couple of weeks - that's a lot of testing and a lot of updates.

3) Agreed - ask your USAID IT friends about FISMA, I'm sure it's as much a pain in their ass as it is mine. But it's the law, and until congress or the administration changes it, it means my jobs is more about locking things down than opening things up. Hopefully this new tech savvy administrtion will start making some changes.

 

ALOKDELTA78

10:46 AM ET

July 24, 2009

The IT Department is the Problem

Wouldn't be the case with Firefox, but yeah good point about the cost of managing two systems. Though I doubt there are a lot of web based applications that they are using.

Resveratrol

 

LONEDESIGNER

10:45 AM ET

August 13, 2009

The key is in "nothing is free"

I saw a small company struggle over the switch from Word to Open Office (just have a look at this article) and although I use OpenOffice myself, I wouldn't say they saved money -at least short term.

So probably this is the meaning of "nothing is free" -just think about the time to retrain users in a large gov agency. It has its weight, and switching browser is not going to be cheaper (while going OO would probably mean long term savings).

 

MICHAEL WILKERSON

3:52 PM ET

August 13, 2009

Actually, while State has

Actually, while State has internal applications that are only secure on IE and would have to be adapted at a cost, Firefox could still be provided for other web browsing like open source research. I'm sure State employees could handle using two different browsers.

 

KEERATI

3:55 PM ET

August 18, 2009

Firefox is

Firefox is the best these days. I can't see the reason why not allow people to use it. It seems IE has to do something i order to be in the top position. online bookmarking site

 

Passport, FP’s flagship blog, brings you news and hidden angles on the biggest stories of the day, as well as insights and under-the-radar gems from around the world.

Read More