Thursday, May 28, 2009 - 1:52 PM
Back in 2007, I wrote a post noting a video of Mohammed Khatami shaking hands with female supporters that had gotten the former Iranian president in some hot water. The post was titled "Mohammed Khatami's macaca moment," but Khatami's latest viral video sensation is actually more like George Allen's infamous racial slur.
In the video, which is making the round of the Iranian blogosphere, Khatami tells an insulting joke about Azeris. (I'm fairly sure it's the video above but Farsi speakers should correct me if I'm wrong.) This had lead to public protests in several cities by Iran's sizeable Azeri community. It's quite possible that the video was leaked in order to discredit Khatami's reformist ally Mir Hossein Musavi in the upcoming presidential election.
RFE/RL's Iran Election Diary Blog provides a translation, though I think it probably loses something from the original:
“There was a preacher from Ardabil whose expertise was telling the story of how Fatemeh Zahra [the daughter of the Prophet Muhammad] got married," he says. "[The preacher] said that the night she became a bride, she was being taken to the house [of the groom] and the Prophet was walking in front of her, while Imam Hassan and Imam Hossein [both the sons of Fatemeh Zahra] were walking with her.”
This is way over my head but the implication, apparently, is that Azeris are slow. In any case, Iran's reformists may want to keep cellphone cameras away from Khatami for the next three weeks.
The same blog also has a collection of (funnier) Iranian election jokes, such as the best reason to vote for Musavi over Ahmadinejad:
"He's made anti-Israeli and anti- American comments at international venues but nobody walked out."
Update: Some further explanation from commenter Nemesida below.
Missing part in the video transcript
Missing part in the video trascript is that Khatami said: I am telling you this to demonstrate the way people in Ardabil think and their intellect. Then someone (could be Khatami, but it is not clear if that is him or not) says "Well he was turk" and everyone in the room laughs.
There is a longer version of this video, when a cleric sitting in the room tells another joke, a story of a loose woman, who came to imam Ali (Prophet Muhammed's nephew) to have her sins forgiven. As the storyteller comments loose woman could be either from Rasht or turk.
So the missing part in the video is Khatami's comment, generalizing mistake of the mullah as an example of people in Ardebil. One may argue that there is nothing serious in this joke. But apparently there are thousands of people in Iran who don't think so. They protested and dozens had been arrested after those protests. However, world media is silent about those arrests. Activists in Iran say human rights organizations in Tehran don't deal with minority cases. International organizations, unfortunately are too much Tehran-oriented.
Best regards
I think some more background on this topic is needed. I am an Iranian American and on my 1st time visit to Iran, I was struck by how ingrained jokes about Azeris are within the Iranian culture. I am in no way condoning such jokes nor do I quite understand the humor in any of it. But having said that, these jokes are told by everyone and everywhere from all social and educated classes, as evidenced by this video. I think to compare Khatami's joke to George Allen's macaca joke is to assume the majority of Iranians would be offended by the telling of that joke in the same way most Americans where with George Allen's. I think most Iranians would not be offended because these jokes are unfortunately very common and a completely acceptable form of "entertainment." I hope one day jokes about ethnic groups like the Azeris won't be condoned but that is not the reality right now in Iran.
Unfortunately it is not just a joke. Azeris in Iran lack basic cultural rights. There are NO SCHOOLS with Azerbaijani education. People get arrested for teaching Azerbaijani turkish in their houses. You are talking about millions of people here (There are different figures on how many Azerbaijanis live in Iran - from 16 millions up to 35 millions). When you are limited in speaking your own language you become a way too sensitive to jokes about your identity. This is just a part of discriminative policy. There is also economic discrimination, too much centralization of the government, unfair distribution of wealth. Plus human rights activists in Tehran refuse to take cases of Azeri activists. Even Iranian Persian speaking opposition abroad - for example in America - is against language rights for non-Persians. I agree with the comment of April the jokes could be innocently made just for entertainment. But again, you never know how sensitive it is untill you get into the shoes of the "second class human being".
Passport, FP’s flagship blog, brings you news and hidden angles on the biggest stories of the day, as well as insights and under-the-radar gems from around the world.
Read More
(3)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE