Argentina expels Holocaust-denying bishop

Thu, 02/19/2009 - 6:10pm

That Bishop Richard Williamson, as a representative of the Vatican, openly and ardently denied the Holocaust's occurrence was a problem. A big problem. As a religious leader it was a position that shouldn't be tolerated. His dismissal from the Church was warranted.

Today however, Argentina's interior ministry announced that the bishop had ten days to leave the country or he would face expulsion, saying that Williamson "has concealed the true motive for his stay in the country." He had said he was an employee of a non-governmental group rather than declaring 'his true activity' as the director of a seminary, the ministry stated."

Wait a minute. Has Williamson broken any laws? No charges have been filed against him. However ignorant, however reprehensible his beliefs, he's entitled to them. This latest action against the bishop seems like blatant persecution and it's a horrendous precedent to set that will no doubt arm more dangerous Holocaust deniers with anti-Semitic rhetoric.  

It's certainly not hard to understand the desire to just get rid of Williamson as quickly as possible, but Argentina just gave him a whole new subject to talk about.

( filed under: )


Advertisement

 

"A representative of the Vatican"?

How is Mons Williamson a "representative of the Vatican"?

And while you attempt to answer that question, I repeat an earlier comment: if you are not going to bother to understand the realities involved with l'affaire Williamson then it would be better--we're all about truth and transparency, right?--to, ahem, keep silence.

Reputation to defend

As a haven for ex-nazis, Argentina needs to be viewed as strongly condemning the Holocaust deniers. Their move is one of self-defense of their reputation, however shaky.

Reason for Expulsion

I don't know about Argentinian immigration law, but under US immigration law, misrepresenting your purpose for being here as Williamson did is grounds for removal. It's called "visa fraud." Williamson was told to leave or "face expulsion," which, presumably, involves charges and some sort of legal process. He can stay and fight the charges--and perhaps win--or leave. What's so outrageous? Happens here every day.