Thursday, October 23, 2008 - 12:05 PM
Austrian politics are turning out to be uncharacteristically interesting these days. Stefan Petzner (right), the successor to Jörg Haider, was sacked yesterday after admitting to having a long-running affair with the leader of Austria's far right.
Haider died earlier this month in a high-speed car crash after drinking heavily at a gay club. Then on Wednesday, Petzner announced that Haider was "the man of my life," and that "we had a special relationship that went far beyond friendship." Before meeting Haider, the 27-year-old Petzner had previously been a journalist writing about cosmetic treatments. His ascent to the head of the party was seen as a fulfillment of Haider's last wish, as Haider had frequently mentioned that he wanted Petzner to succeed him.
Haider's homosexuality had been widely rumored, though the mainstream Austrian press had refrained from reporting on it before Petzner's tell-all interview. Haider became infamous for his seemingly sympathetic views toward the Nazi regime. If only this conflicted man was still alive, and one could confront him with evidence about what the Nazis did to people like him.
The bbc's article really doesn't touch the "they were gay lovers" aspect, just skirting around it - http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7685905.stm
"Kentucky of the Alps" is a nice patronizing epithet, but also not true; the two are incomparable. You're 45 minutes from the Italian border, 45 minutes from the Slovenian border, 2.5 hours from Vienna, 3 hours from Germany and Venice. I would even rate those from the extremely small towns as less provincial than typical American suburbanites. Most there have been to many neighbouring countries, learn 2 foreign languages, have numerous people from other religions (Islam) and asylum seekers from the Bosnia and the Slovenian minority in their neighborhoods. And they get along fine.
Perhaps your version of social conservatism means abhorring people who are bi/gay, but that's your (American? Over 50?) social conservatism; hard to imagine, but in other countries, being socially conservative might mean something else. Even in America you've got Andrew Sullivans.
I hold the line that journalism about domestic politics is more rigorous and informed in Austria than it typically is in the U.S. Comparing, for example, the presidential "debates" with an Austrian debate makes the American debate look like a burlesque. Perhaps they have meandering essays, but Americans have meandering, 24-hour TV news. And having confrontational interviews is a form of speaking truth to power; Haider was regularly interviewed, in a patronizing way, by people who disliked him. (Can you imagine Bush giving a truly confrontational interview?). And remember, his party received practically nil support (<2%) from most states in Austria - so in any case, holding up Haider to represent Austria is incorrect. It seems to me that Americans more often speak power to truth. Here's one Haider interview in English:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akkXPmyHTYA
It certainly isn't your judgement that Haider was a crypto-Nazi - that's the whole point. You are not thinking for yourself, merely parroting what others say. I took a look at the employment quote. Referring to unemployment in the 90s:
-"Na, das hat's im Dritten Reich nicht gegeben, weil im Dritten Reich haben sie ordentliche Beschäftigungspolitik gemacht, was nicht einmal Ihre Regierung in Wien zusammenbringt."
-"No, you didn't have that in the Third Reich, becuase the Third Reich had a decent employment policy - something that your government in Vienna can't even do." (My translation)
This certainly was abominable, and 30s/40s "employment policies" did of course involve slave labour, death, torture. But I think the comment was clearly intended to say, our government is even less competent than the Third Reich. If you're going to call someone a neo-Nazi, follow Orwell, don't dilute the word, find things in their policies that warrant the name. Find a racism-based autocrat who abhors press freedoms, promotes genocide, economic and social regimentation, and the suppression of opposition. That might be someone, but I don't have evidence it was Haider.
Passport, FP’s flagship blog, brings you news and hidden angles on the biggest stories of the day, as well as insights and under-the-radar gems from around the world.
Read More
(2)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE