Global News : Passport : Ricks : Drezner : Walt : Rothkopf : Lynch
The Cable : The AfPak Blog : Net Effect : Shadow Govt. : Madam Secretary : The Call
Jewish voters wary of Palin
Even as Joseph Biden was courting Florida's Jewish voters in Deerfield Beach Tuesday, dropping Yiddishisms like an old pro, it was the McCain campaign that was grabbing the Chosen People's attention.
When Alaska HDTV PodShow host Scott Slone took Palin on an urban hike in February, he captured a telling political detail -- the footage showed that the governor keeps a small Israeli flag by her office window. The flag, naturally, reveals Palin to be a loyal supporter of the Jewish state, despite the fact that she has little experience with Middle East affairs -- she's never visited the region nor has said anything of note on it.
Matt Brooks of the Republican Jewish Coalition, which e-mailed the clip to its list Monday, voiced his enthusiasm:
I think it is extremely telling," he said. "[It] tells her she has Israel in her heart."
While Jewish members of the GOP are using the flag sighting to rally around the vice presidential candidate, others are stewing over news of Palin's alleged support of Pat Buchanan (she wore a Buchanan button when he toured through Alaska in 1999) and a sermon delivered by David Brickner, founder of Jews for Jesus, at Palin's church.
In remarks that began "Well, Shalom!" Brickner observed:
The conflict that is spilled out throughout the Middle East, really which is all about Jerusalem, is an ongoing reflection of the fact that there is judgment [...] Israel has not had the greatest track record when it comes to following after God."
Michael Goldfarb, a spokesman for the McCain-Palin campaign, was quick to make it clear that although Palin was in attendance, she "did not know [Brickner] would be speaking, and she does not share the views [he] expressed. She and her family would not have been sitting in the pews of the church if those remarks were remotely typical."
The Jewish community generally welcomes evangelical Christians' ardent support of Israel, but embracing Jews for Jesus? That's another story. The Anti-Defamation League believes that the San Francisco-based organization "targets Jews for conversion with subterfuge and deception."
As Politico's Ben Smith points out, a Palestinian flag would have incited a far more venomous reaction from the Jewish community. Still, they'll be watching her closely tonight and in the days ahead.














Who in the Jewish Community is wary about Palin?
Ooh, "wary," looks like a fabricated concern to me, the only Jew cited in your post "voiced enthusiasm" for Palin. Palin voted for Forbes not Buchanan, and Buchanan at one time was perceived as mainstream enough to be the 1996 RNC keynote speaker, with his antisemitism bit by bit becoming more apparent. Buchanan of 2008 has, not surprisingly, said that when it comes to Israel/Middle East, he's way more in agreement with Obama than McCain. Palin outright said she disagreed w/at least something of what guest speaker Brickner said in one of the several churches she's happened to have attended. It's likely most in the Jewish community "wary" of Palin were voting Obama anyway.
AIPAC appearance
I assume this is oversight on your part, but While Biden was in Deerfield Beach yesterday, Palin was meeting with AIPAC (and dissing Phyllis Schlafly in the bargain).
http://www.ips.org/blog/jimlobe/?p=186
The fallacy of equating Israel with Judaism
"The Jewish community" is almost a contradiction in terms, judging from my reading of Isaac Beshevis Singer's "Shosha", 1978, which he liked most of his novels.
Someone else defined "shalom" as the ruckus you find at a normal family reunion.
If we assume any relationship between religion and politics, between God and reason, then a Jew who identifies herself by her loyalty to the Basic Laws of Israel is like a Catholic who identifies herself by her loyalty to the Vatican. In other words, that's not much religion and it's pretty lousy politics.
Religion trains you to be skeptical, especially of those who speak in God's name. I'm told "Hasid" means "fear". What's most to fear? "God is not mocked." Singer's Jewish protagonist in "Shosha" defines himself, after escaping Nazi-held Poland and "making it" in the US as a writer and so coming to Israel in 1951 on a book tour or something, as a Jew "because I never beat anyone or killed anyone."