Putin's revenge


While I am still sorting out the claims and counterclaims about who fired the first shots in South Ossetia, one thing is clear: Russian "Prime Minister" Vladimir Putin -- who is already the big winner in this conflict -- is poised to take advantage of it.

Let's dial back the clock to April, when NATO failed to admit Ukraine and Georgia as members. Georgia was told that it must first resolve its "frozen conflicts" with renegade regions Abkhazia and South Ossetia to join. Nobody in NATO relished the prospect of being on the hook for some inscrutable ethnic conflict in the Caucasus.

But, coming on the heels of Kosovo's February declaration of independence, this was practically an invitation to Putin to do his utmost to ensure that Georgia wouldn't ever be stable enough to be a NATO member.

Here's the basic logic:

  • Georgia can't join NATO until it is stable
  • Russia doesn't want Georgia to join NATO
  • Ergo, Russia will destabilize Georgia

The policy had the added bonus of revenge for the Western powers' recognition of Kosovo and it cast doubts on the wisdom of using Georgia as an energy corridor. Plus, it puts the United States in an awkward position and exposes American backing of Georgia as not worth a damned thing. For Putin, it's a quadruple play.

Did Saakashvili miscalculate? Absolutely. He foolishly thought that Georgia could take back South Ossetia before Russia could effectively counterattack, and then the international community would shut the conflict down. But given Putin's brutal logic, this war was probably going to happen one way or another -- it was just a question of when.

UPDATE: Georgia has called a unilateral ceasefire.

... Russian choosing to escalate? The Times reports that Russian troops are attacking Gori.

The Georgians told them, ‘We're done. Let us withdraw," one American military official said. "But the Russians are not letting them withdraw. They are pursuing them, and people are seeing this."

Also, the Bush administration is heading to the U.N. Security Council, where of course Russia will exercise its veto. Putin and Medvedev are refusing to take calls from Saakashvili, and "Western officials" are speculating that the Russians want to oust the Georgian president.


Georgia update

Photo of a bombed structure in Gori, Georgia, by DIMITAR DILKOFF/AFP/Getty Images

Here's the latest on this fast-moving conflict:

  • A reported 1,500 civilians have been killed in the fighting, and Russian tanks continue to flow into South Ossetia. The Russians say they have taken Tskhinvali, the South Ossetian capital, though Georgia claims its forces withdrew of their own accord
  • Russian planes have bombed Gori, a Georgian city due south of Tskhinvali where eyewitnesses describe "scenes of panic"
  • Georgia is calling for a ceasefire but also recalling all 2,000 of its troops from Iraq, with U.S. logistical help [UPDATE: Russia rejects a ceasefire]
  • U.S. President George W. Bush said that Russia's attacks on South Ossetia were a "dangerous escalation" of the conflict
  • Russian President Dmitry Medvedev told Bush in a phone conversation that Russia's aim was "forcing Georgia to accept peace"
  • Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin has left Beijing and is reportedly visiting North Ossetia
  • Politico's Ben Smith wonders if this is a "3 a.m. moment" for the U.S. presidential candidates

UPDATE: The New York Times reports that the situation is "nearing all-out war," with Russia landing troops on Georgia's Black Sea coast.

... John McCreary comments: "Saakashvili gambled and lost. After Russia finishes crippling Georgian military capabilities, negotiations should begin."