No rivals on Team Obama

Fri, 06/20/2008 - 10:46am

From left: Holbrooke, Madeleine Albright, Lake, and AL Gore; FILE: Getty Images

Barack Obama is fond of citing Doris Kearns Goodwin's Team of Rivals, not least because the Illinois senator styles himself as Lincoln's heir, but also because, as he put it to Time's Joe Klein, "The lesson is to not let your ego or grudges get in the way of hiring absolutely the best people."

But if Obama really wanted to put this proposition to the test, he might consider bringing Richard Holbrooke into the fold. Holbrooke, a Democratic Party heavyweight on foreign policy and the point man on the Dayton Accords that ended the Bosnian civil war, was conspicuously absent from Obama's national-security working group, announced Wednesday.

Yes, Holbrooke strongly backed Hillary Clinton in the primary, which probably wasn't a good way to endear him to the eventual nominee. But I mention Holbrooke because of his famous feud with Anthony Lake, who was Bill Clinton's first national security advisor and is now a key member of Team Obama's inner circle. As the late David Halberstam recounts in War In a Time Peace, his book on Clinton-era foreign policy, Holbrooke and Lake were once close friends and rising stars in the diplomatic establishment. But their friendly rivalry turned ugly when Holbrooke was made ambassador to Germany instead of scoring a top job. Halberstam writes:

His slippage in the pecking order in the world of foreign policy was especially painful for Holbrooke friends thought, because Lake ended up with one of the two prized jobs, national security adviser. Their friendship had always had an unstated competitive quality, and now Lake seemed to be the clear winner and had, in Holbrooke's eyes, worked against his place in the administration. As a result, a simmering tension now existed between the two old friends, turning them into genuine enemies.

Their relationship was apparently no better when Holbrooke returned from the German wilderness to take the lead on Bosnia:

Their personal friendship, once so close, had long ago been shattered, and they worked in an atmosphere of barely disguised rivalry and distrust.

So, if he really wanted to be the second coming of Lincoln, Obama would put his money where his mouth is and bring Holbrooke back. At the least, it might inject some much-needed drama back into the campaign.



Advertisement

 

Hounshell seem no like

Hounshell seem no like Obama! Me wonder why.

Holbrooke

Well, drama at least for us Foreign Policy geeks. Holbrooke, I suspect -- and I do not know the man -- is decompressing after making the wrong bet on Hillary, thus allowing the coveted Secretary of State position to slip through his grasp. Obama, quite frankly, has alot of drama to resolve as a result of this campaign, including the broken relationships of Bill Clinton with African-Americans and Bill Clinton with Bill Richardson. He is going to need to truly summon his Inner Abraham Lincoln to get so many rivals at cross-purposes on the same page.

http://ronmwangaguhunga.blogspot.com

Missed the point

Blake,

While I did too notice that Holbrooke was absent, let's put this in in perspective. I'd assume that Holbrooke was absent not because Obama holds anything against him for working for Clinton but because of his history for causing drama with his fellow co-workers. Albright was a much more outspoken person for Clinton on the campaign trail and following your logic she shouldn't have been invited. No drama is an underlying theme of the Obama campaign and like him or not, Holbrooke brings a tremendous amount of drama not matter where he goes.

I'm personally a fan of the man but besides the point made above, it probably doesn't help his cause that his wife's name turned up on the VIP list of the Countrywide mortgage company that have landed two senators in hot water and got Jim Johnson the boot from the VP search team. Just after Johnson was asked to leave and two Senators are under investigation are you going to add a senior person, no matter how great, whose wife received these special loans?

good points, all

I must admit that the post is a little tongue in cheek -- I don't really expect Obama to bring Holbrooke on board, for all of the reasons that JB points out. I do think Obama's rhetoric about "Team of Rivals" is more about appearing bipartisan than about actually being bipartisan. But I suppose we'll find out.