Global News : Passport : Ricks : Drezner : Walt : Rothkopf : Lynch
The Cable : The AfPak Blog : Net Effect : Shadow Govt. : Madam Secretary : The Call
Jimmy Carter wanted to meet with Islamic Jihad?
Dog bites man. A Commentary magazine blogger slams Jimmy Carter for meeting with Hamas leaders.
But there's more. Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ) says it turned down a meeting request from Carter, whom the terrorist group accused of "carrying an American-Israeli agenda." (Funny, most of Carter's critics would say he's carrying water for the Palestinians.) Commentary's Eric Trager says the incident "should finally shatter Carter's credibility as a peacemaker." He explains:
While PIJ shares many of Hamas' militant features–including its coordination of terrorist activities, calls for Israel's destruction, and theocratic aims–PIJ lacks Hamas' social and political significance. It does not have the social welfare network on which Hamas has built its popularity, while PIJ's refusal to participate in the 2006 parliamentary elections points to its minimal public authority among Palestinians.
There are many valid reasons to meet with Hamas, most notably because no peace process can possibly succeed if the Islamist movement is outside the tent trying to blow it up. Carter is right about that, and many Israelis know it. But if it's true that the former U.S. president wanted to meet with the odious PIJ as well, then it shows he hasn't learned a whole lot about politics in his 83 years. To say the least.













Is it possible that PIJ
Is it possible that PIJ could have done this in an attempt to discredit Carter?
I'm really surprised that
I'm really surprised that this item was printed here.
"This news should finally shatter Carter’s credibility as a peacemaker." That really says it all: It's not news - it's an allegation. And allegations should not be printed as news.
Nor was it...
... I made clear that it was Islamic Jihad making the claim.