Global News : Passport : Ricks : Drezner : Walt : Rothkopf : Lynch
The Cable : The AfPak Blog : Net Effect : Shadow Govt. : Madam Secretary : The Call
Ireland putting the brakes on immigration?

If you've seen the recent Irish film Once -- which just won an Oscar for best song -- you may understand how much the social fabric of Ireland has been changing over the last 10 years. In the film, an Irish street performer falls for a young Czech immigrant, who lives with her mother and daughter in a small flat, shares one TV set with her entire building in a poor Dublin neighborhood, and sells flowers in the street to make ends meet. Although living in difficult circumstances, the immigrant family still manages a happy ending. According to the New York Times, however, such characters typify the new Irish identity, and not everyone in Ireland is thrilled about it.
In the last decade, Ireland has seen an explosion in immigration equal to that experienced in Britain over the last 50 years, and from over 150 different nations. For over a century before that, Ireland was better known for its emigration rate, which may be partly why no thoughtful immigration laws were ever put in place. And although FP put the country on a list of the world's most immigrant-friendly countries, some on the Emerald Isle fear a threat to Irish culture and history.
Recently, Enda Kenny, leader of the Irish parliamentary party Fine Gael, released a statement calling for a "genuine national debate" on immigration and for immigrants to acknowledge that they have both rights and responsibilities -- not least of which to realize that Ireland is a "Christian celtic" state. He has since been forced to defend those comments, which were characterized by commentators as highly xenophobic. While the debate has not yet reached the levels of rancor found in other European countries, Ireland is clearly reaching a threshold, and films like Once may have very different endings in this uncertain Irish future.













It was a beautiful song
And four major acting awards went to non Americans. Hollywood continues full steam ahead with its global talent strategy, to continue growing box office receipts.
immigration and ireland
Enda Kenny´s press statement dates from January 2007 - and 15 months ago is hardly "recently" as you put it in the post. Furthermore, Kenny made the statement as part of the run-up to a general election - one in which anti-immigrant parties and candidates failed to even secure enough votes to keep their deposit, let alone win any seats. In fact, Ireland has immigrants who have won seats in local elections, something that the anti-immigrant campaigners have singularly failed to do.
with regard to your comparison of Ireland´s experience with immigration with that of England 50 years ago. In what way are they comparable? The reasons and legalities are completely different. The immigrants who came to England 50 years ago did so as members of the British commonwealth. In fact, one of the interesting aspects of the British experience was the sense of identity that those commonwealth immigrants brought with them - one that saw the Queen as their Queen and as Britain as somehow a "mother" country. The realities those immigrants faced upon arrival were completely out of step with their expectations of identity and affinity.
With Ireland, the immigration has been purely economic, although thousands of immigrants have made the decision to settle down and make Ireland their adopted country.
We do not have a colonial past with Poland or China or Hungary, one where we were the mother country and Poland et al the colonized.
There have been problems with immigration and Ireland, but the idea that somehow those problems have reached a threshold on a par with Enoch Powell and "rivers of Blood" is ridiculous.
www.dublinopinion.com