Afghan farmers say no to opium, yes to pot


A major victory has been scored in war against opium cultivation in Afghanistan. In the Northern Province of Balkh, once home to 27,000 acres of poppies, opium cultivation has been nearly eradicated. Balkh's achievement can be attributed largely to stepped up enforcement, prosecution of poppy farmers, and the increasing prevalence of an alternative crop. And that crop is... marijuana.

As The New York Times reported Sunday, many farmers in Balkh are switching to cannabis, which has been cultivated in the region for over 70 years. Other than poppies, farmers say that cannabis is the only crop they can grow that will feed their families. Farmers can earn almost twice as much for the stuff as they do for an equal amount of legal crops like cotton. Balkh's tough-on-drugs governor, Atta Mohammed Noor, has held back so far, but he has no plans to allow the cultivation to continue:

Mr. Atta says he has a plan to eradicate cannabis next growing season. Farmers have begun to harvest their current crop, and officials say they do not want to destroy the farmers' livelihood without giving them time to plant an alternative.

"Marijuana is not difficult to control, like poppy," the governor said in an interview in October in his vast, opulent office in Mazar-i-Sharif. "It's very easy to eradicate. It's a very simple issue."

Perhaps, but that doesn't answer the question of why he would bother. Is it really worth spending Afghanistan's meager financial resources (and the United States' for that matter) trying to eradicate a profitable and non-harmful alternative to one of the country's greatest social ills? Atta says the province is still waiting for development money to help farmers grow alternative crops. That would be a good step of course, but in the meantime can we really justify punishing farmers for finding their own alternatives?

Balkh's farmers aren't the only ones thinking differently about Afghanistan's poppy problem. Last week the European Parliament endorsed a proposal to license a limited number of Afghan farmers to grow poppies for use in medicines, such as morphine. Similar schemes have worked in the past in Pakistan and Thailand. The idea is not without its problems. It would be hard to justify allowing one village to grow poppies while eradicating them in another. And even under the most optimistic projections, farmers would still earn far less legally then they would by selling to drug traffickers. Still, it's promising that some leaders are looking for creative new ways to, as Ethan Nadelman suggests, limit the harm caused by illegal drugs rather than perpetuating an endless war to eradicate them.


Morning Brief, Tuesday, November 6

Note: Technical difficulties on the blog held up postings this morning. Our apologies for the delay.


AFP/Getty Images

Pakistan's ousted chief justice called for Pakistanis to "rise up" against Pervez Musharraf. Clashes between lawyers and police continued for a second day as the Pakistani leader ignored a call from U.S. President George W. Bush to lift the state of emergency, hold elections, and resign as chief of staff of the Army. On Monday, unfounded rumors of a coup prompted a stock market crash in Karachi. Western diplomats, meanwhile, worry that Musharraf's crackdown is distracting his security forces from going after terrorists and extremists.

Efforts to disable North Korea's Yongbyon reactor are "off to a good start," a U.S. State Department official said.

Another big IPO in China, this time for, an e-commerce firm, which is now valued at 316 times earnings.

Middle East

Flush with oil revenues, Libya is going capitalist.

President Bush agreed Monday to help Turkey combat the PKK, but Turkish PM Tayyip Erdogan says a military offensive in northern Iraq is still in the cards and that "Nobody is telling us not to do an operation."

Americans are roughly evenly divided on whether to strike Iran, a new USA Today/Gallup poll has found. 


British PM Gordon Brown laid out a new agenda in an attempt to fend off accusations of "drift".

The European Union is getting tough on terrorism. Al Qaeda remains the greatest threat to Europe, the EU counterterrorism chief says.

Italian authorities are searching for 20 men suspected of plotting attacks in Afghanistan and Iraq.


The dollar's continued fall means the markets are betting that the Fed will lower interest rates for a third time, Bloomberg reports.

Former Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan warned that it could take months before the full extent of banks' losses from the subprime mortgage crisis become clear.

Scientists have begun to unlock the genetic secrets of dandruff.

Today's Agenda

Yesterday on Passport